Latest/Most JoomlaComments

Can you be "Reformed" and "Charismatic" at the same time? PDF Print E-mail

Tags: charismatic-theology | church | heresy | reformed-theology

User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Blogs
Tuesday, 15 September 2009 01:45

Michelle is a reformed charismatic, in the sense that she was once charismatic and has reformed herself from it. Much like a reformed smoker. In fact the similarities are striking. Like reformed smokers, reformed charismatics like this are intensely angry about anyone who practises charismatic theology or who shows evidence of being charismatic in their Christian life.

But what we mean by the form "Reformed Charismatic" is, in reality, somewhat different from "reformed smoker". We are referring to someone who claims to have theology that is both "Reformed' (put simply, 'Calvinistic' or, basically, strongly from the reformation) and "Charismatic" (that is, expresses Christian life with an expectation that the activity of the Spirit of God as portrayed in the Book of Acts must, of necessity, continue today).

Personally, I believe that charismatic theology is a pious heresy. Pious because charismatics seek to honour God in their charismatic worship, and they genuinely believe that non-Charismatics deny the Spirit of God because we don't  bang on about him all the time. Heresy because it is clear in Scripture that the Spirit of God always does the bidding of the Father and the Son, and does so in order to glorify them, so to bang on about the Spirit is, in my understanding of Scripture, to dishonour God by honouring a part of him that seeks not to be honoured.

John Woodhouse explains this a lot better than I:

Phillip Jensen interviews John Woodhouse - Reformed Charismatics from Audio Advice on Vimeo.

Comments
Add New Search RSS
Peter S  - Charisphobia   |source203.51.113.54 |18-01-2010 00:35:52
Like Ruth B, I have been seeking clarity on this issue for over one year. The
thing which stands out to me is that both Phillip Jensen and John Woodhouse have
no difficulty with God working in a miraculous fashion today but as they don't
see anything happening (apart from what makes the font page re Mary MxKillop)
their lack of experience of miracles tells them don't happen today. The problem
here is I have heard of miracles even in our local area but more that that in
Africa and Asia. Now these miracles are either false (ie. The Gospel is preached
but satan performs the miracles) or they are true. If they are true, how do I
deal with that? I also have heard a number of clergy give off the cuff comments
re the evils of charismatics (usually re prosperity doctrine) without explaining
what they mean. If give the congregation the impression that all charismatics
are somehow evil unlike the correct position of the anglican Christian...
Jen S  - ooh ok then.   |source122.148.86.245 |26-11-2009 20:55:56
still confused after vid. maybe my brain is a little slow today.
Glenn E Farrell  - re: re: them charismatics..   |Administrator |26-11-2009 09:08:04
avatar
Glenn wrote:

I wouldn't quote call
G.[/color][/size]


That's quite, not quote! D'oh!
Glenn  - re: them charismatics..   |source203.33.164.248 |26-11-2009 09:05:52
Jen S wrote:
so.. charismatics are the slightly loopy ones carrying on all the time?(as
in every sentence must contain scripture) or are they the
aerobecise christians? or is that pentecostals? hmmm I think I need to
ask you this one in persona!


I wouldn't quote call them slightly loopy... ok, I would. Meh, it's
easier to answer it in person like you said.

G.
Jen S  - them charismatics..   |source122.148.86.245 |25-11-2009 09:27:35
so.. charismatics are the slightly loopy ones carrying on all the time?(as in
every sentence must contain scripture) or are they the aerobecise christians? or
is that pentecostals? hmmm I think I need to ask you this one in persona!
Ruth B   |source121.79.22.166 |15-09-2009 16:19:56
Actually Glenn, I found your explanation much clearer than John's! And I've
been seeking a good understanding of this topic for over a year now. Thanks.
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
 
:angry::0:confused::cheer:B):evil::silly::dry::lol::kiss::D:pinch:
:(:shock::X:side::):P:unsure::woohoo::huh::whistle:;):s
:!::?::idea::arrow:
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

3.23 Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."